Halladay trade! WHIR

[mcope]

Batting: TB, BB, K, R, RBI, SB
Pitching: IP, ER, W, L, S, BS, K, BB, H, SO, CG, QS

I've been working on a package for Halladay for a while now, but his owner hasn't budged until now. I was recently offered this trade:

Dan Haren, Micheal Young and Jay Bruce for Roy Halladay, Yadier Molina and Chris Chris Coghlan.

I lost Buster Posey and have Soto currently starting, I could use an upgrade there. I do feel as though I am losing a big time OF in Bruce for someone such as Coghlan. I do feel like there is a better trade to be made for Halladay and don't want to lose Bruce if I don't have to.

My Roster
C: Geovany Soto
1B: Ryan Howard
2B: Brandon Phillips
3B: Evan Longoria
SS: Elvis Andrus
OF: Andrew McCutchen
OF: Jay Bruce
OF: Corey Patterson
UT: Micheal Young
BN: Jose Tabata
BN: Derek Jeter

Starters (Start 5)
CC Sabathia
Dan Haren
AJ Burnett
Hiroki Kuroda
Matt Garza
Dillon Gee
Jhoulys Chacin
Madison Bumgarner

Relievers
Carlos Marmol
Ryan Madson

His Roster
C: Yadier Molina
1B: Justin Smoak
2B: Daniel Murphy
3B: Ryan Roberts
SS: Stephen Drew
OF: Carlos Gonzalez
OF: Logan Morrison
OF:Matt Joyce
UT: Erick Aybar
BN: Chris Coghlan
BN:JP Arencibia
DL: Ryan Zimmerman

Starters (Start 5)
Roy Halladay
Jon Lester
CJ Wilson
Ian Kennedy
Colby Lewis
Alexi Ogando
Jonny Venters

Relievers
Papelbon
McClellan

[berrymyers]

I think you're giving up way to much here. personally I'd rather have Soto in my C spot. Also, the drop off in OF production isn't worth the slight upgrade in SP you get.

[irollaround]

I'd tell him to get lost. Your giving up a ton and he's not even close to compensating you.

Help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=432827

[MadDog36]

an Haren, Micheal Young and Jay Bruce

side wins easily, Young is no slouch himself and Bruce is the best value here. no deal.