Crawford/Duffy for C. Santana/CC/D. Young - WHIR for sure!

[Bea Arthur]

20 team, H2H keeper (5 keepers), OBP vs. AVG. Currently in 1st in my division but I've been devastated by injuries. Just got offered C. Santana/Buchholz/Zambrano/D. Young for Crawford and Duffy. He's looking to have a firesale and rebuild. I was going to counter with Crawford and Duffy for Sabathia/C. Santana and Delmon Young. Good deal? Or maybe sub in Heyward for Crawford in the original deal and see if he'll do it?

My lineup:

C- Soto
1B - Votto
2B - Cano
SS - S. Rodriguez
3B - Aviles
OF - Crisp
OF - Crawford
OF - Lo. Morrison
UTIL - Hosmer
DL - Heyward
DL - Furcal
BN (DL) - P. Alvarez
BN (DL) - Hafner

SP - Chacin
SP - G. Gonzalez
SP - Garza
SP - Collmenter
SP - C. Carasco
SP - D. Duffy
RP - Santos
RP - Walden
RP - Bard

[ahcryky]

If you're trying to get a better SS, you have to get more then Stubbs if you're packaging Crawford. I like the Prado deal to upgrade your 3B without having to give up too much.

[ATLbraves]

If you're trying to get a better SS, you have to get more then Stubbs if you're packaging Crawford. I like the Prado deal to upgrade your 3B without having to give up too much.

Yeah I like the Prado deal too, that seems like a much better option depending on who else you have to package. Even though I am not a big fan of Zambrano or Dempster, I would def go with Z. In the Crawford deal you aren't getting enough in return, see if he can up the ante or try and make a counter-offer.

[sigriffey]

I'm not privy to what the stub s deal was, but I really like the one with CC. Yes, losing Crawford is tough but CC is great and I see Carlos Santana getting it back again.

Dont mess with those cubs pitchers. U never know what ur gonna get.

[mchapple78]

pretty much agree, if you can get CC then do it. Stay away from Big Z at all cost.

I believe Santana picks it up soon, at least he better, i've been waiting for him all year!!!

[mbfan1982]

I agree with the Sabathia camp. Zambrano is a headcase. CC is a stud. Get CC if you can.

[raek]

I would not do the offered deal, but I would with CC. Your staff does need help, and looks like you would replace Crawford with CC for keepers.