Do I Trade Lincecum/Kershaw for Jose Reyes?

[rasto21585]

In my 20 team h2h dynasty league I was offered Jose Reyes for either my Kershaw or Lincecum. I think this trade would help out my team a lot but I am a little gunshy breaking up my big 3. What do you recommend I do? Team is belOw.

[ahcryky]

I don't see any team.........

[rasto21585]

Here's my team


20 team h2h dynasty league

c j.p. arencibia
1b miguel cabrera
2b neil walker
3b evan longoria
ss yunel escobar
inf edwin encarnacion
lf jose tabata
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of peter bourjos
util coco crisp
bn chase headley
bn russell martin
bn ryan theriot



sp clayton kershaw
sp jon lester
sp tim lincecum
sp colby lewis
rp jason motte
rp sergio santos
rp vincente padilla
rp rafael soriano
p aaron harang
p jason ingrnhausen
p homer bailey
bn jason hammel
bn scott downs
bn matt harrisson
dl scott kazmir

[ahcryky]

Nope, you're pitching staff definitely can't take a hit like that. It would be nice to get Reyes, but that's a steep price for you.

[irollaround]

You could easily take the hit, but I'm not sure Reyes is worth it. You got young elite pitchers, and Reyes is getting older and is an injury waiting to happen. I wouldn't do it.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=432696

[ahcryky]

You could easily take the hit, but I'm not sure Reyes is worth it. You got young elite pitchers, and Reyes is getting older and is an injury waiting to happen. I wouldn't do it.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=432696

Young elite? Where? Oh, you must mean the pitchers he's trading away.....

[Bolthead04]

I would consider Kershaw for Reyes, but I'd advise against it. Reyes is good, but I don't trust how long he would hold up. Throw in what your staff would look like after the trade and it's not all that desirable of a trade.

It's a risk/reward deal, and I'd sit on it. If you went for it, I wouldn't blame you. But, it's not the most solid deal for you.

Cheers!