Justin Upton Trade

[mgerrish@johare.com]

Hey Guys,

I need a little help with this one. What do you think about:

I Give: Justin Upton and Garza
I Get: Utley, Pagan and Oswalt

Thanks!!!

[rjforlife]

Without seeing your roster, I don't really care for it. Pagan has come back playing pretty well but he is really only good for steals. Garza is now OFF the DL so him for Oswalt you gain some pitching, but not a ton. And Utley has looked OK, but not fully his former self, while Upton is looking like the 30/30 monster people have been waiting for. If you can upgrade Pagan it would be a different story, or if you really need pitching/outfield help my opinion may differ. Post your roster so we can get a better idea.




Help:

viewtopic.php?t=432652

[mgerrish@johare.com]

I have a VERY offensive roster...

C: Y. Molina
1B: Adrian Gonzo
2B: Cano
SS: Andrus
3B: A-Rod
2B/SS: Phillips
1B/3B: Miggy Cabrera
OF: Granderson
OF: J. Upton
OF: Pierre
OF: Victorino
Util: Gaby Sanchez
Util: Moreland
Bench: McGehee and Dominic Brown

Pitching: Sabathia, Beckett, Garza, Gio Gonzalez, Loshe, Anabel Sanchez and Nolasco

[rjforlife]

Pierre/Victorino/Andrus makes Pagan essentially worthless. I would like to see Pagan/Oswalt turn into a better arm or Pagan/Utley into an elite option. I don't like 3-2 when the 3rd guy you get does nothing for you. If it has to be a 3-2, get a pitcher instead of Pagan, someone like Brett Anderson or Daniel Hudson or someone of that calibur.

[HOOTIE]

bad deal