drop justin masterson for josh collmenter? WHIR

[fierro33]

i would move ike davis to the DL and drop beachy for him

[rjforlife]

I don't agree with any of these guys. I have no clue why everyone is defending Masterson. He had a hot start, big deal. The guy has proven himself to be crap, and has always pitched that way. Cleveland started hot, but has been cooling down, and almost no one as much as Masterson. He won't keep an ERA under 4, and that means 4.50+ from here on out. He doesn't K many guys, and his win total will be good, but not overwhelming. I would much rather take a shot on a young upstart like Collmenter than hang onto failed garbage like Masterson. Make the move I know you want to make, it's the right one.


Help:

viewtopic.php?t=432652

[fast dogs]

Theres always the chance Beachy loses his spot to Minor if he comes back not as effective.I think Hous would want Lyon to get re-established so they can trade him