This maybe a simple no brainer. Yes or no?

[ECG77]

I being offered Nate McLouth (on the DL) for my Nate Schierholtz.

5X5 National League Rotisserie Scoring
Batting Categories:
BA, HR, R, RBI, SB
Pitching Categories:
ERA, K, S, W, WHIP

Active
C: McCann, Brian ATL
C: Morales, Jose COL
1B: Wallace, Brett HOU
2B: Espinosa, Danny WAS
3B: Jones, Chipper ATL
SS: Ramirez, Hanley FLA
MI: Cedeno, Ronny PIT
CI: Rolen, Scott CIN
OF: Bernadina, Roger WAS
OF: Gonzalez, Carlos COL
OF: Nix, Laynce WAS
OF: Pence, Hunter HOU
OF: Schierholtz, Nate SF
U: Bloomquist, Willie ARI

P: Bailey, Homer CIN
P: Bell, Heath SD
P: Garcia, Jaime STL
P: Garza, Matt CHC
P: Marshall, Sean CHI
P: Oswalt, Roy PHI
P: Rodriguez, Francisco NYM
P: Sanchez, Anibal FLA
P: Vogelsong, Ryan SF

Bench: Isringhausen, Jason NYM
Bench: Hernandez, David ARI
Bench: LaRoche, Adam WAS
Bench: Keppinger, Jeff HOU

[Devil Doc]

Neither player is appealing to me, I think its a flip of a coin. I think Schierholtz is eventually going to lose playing time to Belt, and not to mention the Giants also have Cody Ross and Burrell as well. Upside...I think McLouth has a better upside mainly because he'll have no one to really compete with him when he returns from the DL. Hinske maybe, but I haven't heard of the Braves bringing up anyone else from the minor league system...but i'd have to research that to be sure.

Help with mine please

[ECG77]

I agree. I think McLouth has more value being a starting player. I don't think Hinske is threat to take that job. Schierholtz being a part of crowded OF has been rumored in the trade market.