2 possible trade offers WHIR

[germani40]

What deal would be better for me? What I am trying to accomplish is getting a pitcher because my pitching staff is very weak. I am also trying to do a trade so I can free up a roster spot for when Hafner will be coming off the DL in the next week or so.

Deal #1

I give
Zobrist
Beltran

I get
Ian Kennedy

Deal #2

I give
Zobrist
Beltran
Broxton
Fuentes

I get
Chacin
Leo Nunez

[jruffus1]

#2, even though I really don't like either trade.

[High cheese]

maybe deal #2 if you are truly desperate but you're giving up too much either way

[Millhouse]

I don't like either one of those. Zobrist still has some name bigger value (vs. actual performance), can peddle that for more than Ian Kennedy, I think.

[r8rferg]

You're giving up too much in each of those deals. I wouldn't do it.
Little help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=432435

[RyeWhiskey]

Are these two deals with the same team? If so, I'd like something like:

Beltran
Zobrist
Broxton
Fuentes

for

Chacin
Kennedy
Nunez

Fuentes is trash since Bailey is back. Broxton may never regain control of the closer role. Beltran is a nice sell-high. And Zobrist is the only real value on your side. So if you can pull 2 quality SPs and a top closer, I'd do it for sure.

[carpediem]

Thanks for helping with mine!

I agree with the others, you are giving up too much. Zobrst is too versatile and has flashes of greatness at the plate, and Beltran is quietly putting together a nice season ... and he will likely get traded out of spacious Citi field by July.

I'd offer just one or the other for either pitcher.

[whitheadsuxs]

none of these deals all sound terrible to me