Victorino for Carpenter WHIR

[jaysfreak13]

So I was offerred this trade just wondering what you think Carpenter has been struggling all year and wondering if he will turn it sround in the 2nd half. Just a couple things

1. I have to drop someone to do this(I have to do it anyways to activate him and it will likely be Brett Gardner in fact I will have probably dropped him by the time you read this)
2. He also has Lincecum and Tommy Hanson on there and wondering if I should target them instead as well.

Likely considering counterofferring it here's my roster

C Russell Martin NYY
1B/3B Kevin Youkilis BOS
2B Dan Uggla ATL
3B Alex Rodriguez NYY
OF Carl Crawford BOS
OF Michael Bourn HOU
OF Carlos Quentin CHW
UTL/1B Paul Konerko CHW
BN Brett Gardner NYY
DL Shane Victorino PHI

SP Shaun Marcum MIL
SP Max Scherzer DET
RP Mark Melancon HOY
RP Chris Perez CLE
P Drew Storen WSH
P Andrew Bailey OAK
P Kyle Lohse STL
BN Annibal Sanchez FLA
BN Colby Lewis TEX
BN Eric Bedard SEA
BN Johnny Cueto CIN

[plainyogurt]

who knows if carpenter will turn it around. Two things with him. You can get him for cheap now, but he will always be a injury liability. You would need to trrade top notch for lincecum, I would go after hanson and see what he wants in return

[CyboNinja]

See if he'll do Victo for Hansen straight up. You're very deep in SBs and don't really need Victo imo.

[billycent]

If you can get Hanson for Vic, I say jump all over it, but given the ways he's pitched so far and the fact that ur not exactly deep at OF... I think I'd pass on Carp.

[emeraldcitysaints]

Carpenter is too risky and may just be getting a bit too old and injury prone to give up a player like Vic.
Targeting Hansen would seem like the most even deal.

Help on mine - viewtopic.php?t=432375

[jaysfreak13]

thanks I counterofferred for Tommy Hanson and it ended up getting rejected I`m considering other options he has Jeremy Helickson rookie Rays SP wonder about him hmmm....