WHIR! Dunn/Zimmerman opinion needed

[elvis1074]

If I am giving up Adam Dunn/Michael Morse/Melancon for Ryan Zimmerman is that fairish?

I do need power but Dunn is killing my BA. The other team needs saves.

[studepaber]

Who is your 3B now? I guess it seems fair. Dunn may heat up soon, who knows if Morse can keep up the #'s, Zimmerman should be back in the lineup in a few weeks.

[Sanjgrass87]

I dont know.. this is tough cause zimmerman needs to get back first and start off hot right away... morse is heating up and adam dunn well yea the donkey only gets homers here and there....i would say no though.. just cause of the upside of morse.. and in a lineup of the whitesox he hits in the heart of it sooo he will get rbis and homers.. so hold on to them for now ... if you could check out my trade the TULO for cargo and Price one that would be great! thanks

[elvis1074]

I have Longoria at 3b, Youk at CI and Howard at 1B. Zimmerman would be taking over UTL for Dunn. Morse is the question mark here. If he can keep it up then I am giving too much away.

[zomberg]

Who is available on the wire currently?

[VitiumCloud]

Dunn is garbage, and it was inevitable for him to hit this downward spiral with his strikeout rate. It's smart for you to jump ship. I'd take this deal since you probably won't be able to get a much better value.


My thread:
viewtopic.php?t=432340

[cofinator]

I think you can play the waiting game with Dunn and just play Morse..... your depending on zimmerman to be hot once
he comes off the DL and stay hot. Granted he is a great player and will put up solid numbers but i think your giving up
too much in the trade to depend on zimmerman. Also Dunn will come around ...eventually.... and when he does you will
be better off with the both of them in your lineup as in Morse and Dunn then just zimmerman. Try to see if you can swing
maybe just morse and melancolon for zimmerman then i think it would be a better trade for you.

[High cheese]

I think you can play the waiting game with Dunn and just play Morse..... your depending on zimmerman to be hot once
he comes off the DL and stay hot. Granted he is a great player and will put up solid numbers but i think your giving up
too much in the trade to depend on zimmerman. Also Dunn will come around ...eventually.... and when he does you will
be better off with the both of them in your lineup as in Morse and Dunn then just zimmerman. Try to see if you can swing
maybe just morse and melancolon for zimmerman then i think it would be a better trade for you.

Not likely to be accepted. Better off trying Dunn/Melancon and hope for the best.