Help Me Pick My Keepers!

[smithmn]

Hey guys, I need to keep four players for next season... let me know who you would keep.

C - Jonathan Lucroy MIL
1B - Gaby Sanchez FLA
2B - Jed Lowrie BOS
3B - Placido Polanco PHI
SS - Jimmy Rollins PHI
OF - Carl Crawford BOS
OF - Logan Morrison FLA
OF - Jacoby Ellsbury BOS
UT - David Ortiz BOS
BN - Adam Jones BAL
BN - Adam Dunn CHI
DL - Ryan Zimmeran WAS

SP - Jon Lester BOS
SP - Trevor Cahill OAK
SP - Josh Johnson FLA
SP - Justin Masterson CLE
RP - Heath Bell SD
RP - Neftali Feliz TEX
P - Jordan Walden LAA
P - Jason Hammel COL
P - Chris Carpenter STL
P - Ricky Romero TOR

Right now, I'm thinking for sure Crawford (I expect him to pick it up, especially in the nasty Boston lineup). Also, Zimmerman should be back in a couple weeks, I expect him to return to form. After that is where I'm struggling. Do I go with a winning pitcher in Lester? Dominant guy like Johnson who has been injury prone? Ellsbury?

Opinions would be greatly appreciated.

[Brewins33]

Gaby
Crawford
Zimmerman
Lester

[avsfan4ever33]

Why are you picking so early? Or is this just a hypothetical "if the season were to end today" sort of thing?

Anyways, my four would be:

OF - Carl Crawford BOS
DL - Ryan Zimmerman WAS
SP - Jon Lester BOS
SP - Josh Johnson FLA

[smithmn]

Yes, it was hypothetical. We obviously won't pick until after the season. But it's my first keeper league, so was just interested in some opinions.

Thanks!

[whitheadsuxs]

avsfan4ever33 is exactly right with those 4 and if you dont wanna keep two pitchers take adam dunn for a bounce back year in 2012