BJ Upton/Uggla for Hamilton/Swisher

[johnlee1986]

I give up BJ Upton/Uggla for josh hamilton and swisher.. it's a keeper league and all of these players mentioned are 4 year keepers.

I'm not liking the swisher part of the deal, i feel like uggla for hamilton is a good 1 for 1 (a bit more value on hamilton's side if he stays healthy, and given uggla will bounce back mid season and he can't continue to play this bad for 4 years)

and upton for swisher is too much, upton has too much going for him (i feel he can hit 20hr/40sb here on out)

im looking to counter with upton/uggla for hamilton/rios... thoughts??

my team is
Napoli, Miranda, Uggla, Bautista, HanleyRam, Eric Young JR, BJ Upton, Melky Cab, Belt, Delmon Young, Denard Span, Derrek Lee, Vernon Wells, Hafner.

[whofox]

I pretty much agree with your analysis, Swisher is the problem. Hamilton is amazing but can he stay healthy. Rios seems inconsistent year to year but probably a better piece to get than Swisher.

Post it on tradebashers and see how the vote comes out. You input the players and league details and everybody votes.