Anderson, Buchholz, Floyd - who will be better?

[Hamilton73]

Need to trade for a pitcher - one team that is interested has Brett Anderson, Gavin Floyd and Clay Buchholz available - who do you think is going to be best the remainder of the year (or rank the three as I may try and get 2 of them). I am in a 10 team AL only league. Hitting points for HR, SB, Hits, Runs, RBI's. Pitching points for IP's (1), K's(1), Walks (-1), Wins (10) and Losses (-3). Any help would be appreciated. Will probably move one of my OF's for one of them.

CARLOS SANTANA
MICHAEL YOUNG
ROBINSON CANO
ADRIAN BELTRE
ERICK AYBAR
CARL CRAWFORD
BJ UPTON
SHIN SOO CHOO
CURTIS GRANDERSON - DH
JUSTIN VERLANDER
DAN HAREN
KYLE DRABEK
ZACH BRITTON
PHILIP HUMBER
MARIANO RIVERA

Bench:
DANNY DUFFY
MARK TRUMBO
JOSH WILLINGHAM

[knittedmonkey]

Id rank as follows:
Bucholz (advantage being on the best team)
Anderson
Floyd

[bigoz89]

I would probably go with

Anderson
Buchholz
Floyd

Buchholz will most likely have the wins, but I think Anderson does everything else better.

A little help? viewtopic.php?t=432118

[Hamilton73]

Thanks for the responses - I like Anderson to have the biggest upside but the injury possibility does scare me with him as well
as does the lack of offense to support him in Oakland.