huge huge huge trade on table please please help

[SEK1971]

my bautista/tulo/berkman/stubbs for cargo/pujols/reyes/j upton

aybar would replace bautista at 3rd

10 TEAM H2H CBS LEAGUE TOTAL POINTS NO CATEGORIES WEEKLY SCORING

VMART
HOWARD
PEDROIA
TULO
J BAUTISTA
KEMP
STUBBS
MORSE
JOYCE

BENCH
NAPOLI
BERKMAN
HUNTER
AYBAR

NOLASCO
LOHSE
KENNEDY
BEDARD
CJ WILSON
MARMOL
N FELIZ
AXFORD

[jruffus1]

I do not like this trade at all. You would be the one giving up the best player in baseball.

[jparks21]

I like it. I see you upgrading in 3 spots, while only downgrading @ 3B a weak position to begin with. You may even be able to flip someone for a 3B later on and still have a better team. I would do it.

[ahcryky]

I really don't see the point of this trade........ Are you bored with your team? I think a better strategy would be to take one of your bench players like Berkman or Hunter and upgrade your pitching.

[DerekBDoherty]

I take this trade, if you think there are managers who would actively trade in your league. Yes, you are giving up the *currently* best player in baseball, but you're getting too much in return to pass it up.

Problem is, this trade doesn't necessarily make your everyday starting line-up better. You take a HUGE hit at 3B, in exchange for getting a very serious upgrade at OF and 1B. You'll have to swing another trade, maybe giving up some OF/1B for a good 3B and a stud SP to supplement a somewhat weak staff (your bats are great, even for a 10 team league).

But overall, you are getting more value, by a pretty decent margin too.