I've asked a question about trading MCab in another thread, and now I've found a trading partner who's interested to deal and I've made the offer which has been rejected so I want suggestions...
My offer was MCab + Rollins for Tulo + Hamels. He's a bit reluctant but is willing to negotiate. I have a Shortstop and Starting pitcher rotation problem. My idea is to strengthen my weak spots and use Konerko at 1st Base. I think the added points Tulo and Hamels bring can make up for the lost points of using Konerko instead of MCab.
His counter was: MCab + Weaver + Madson + Ellsbury for Ryan Howard + Hamels + Cahill + Soria + Prado. I turned that down already since I have no space for extra players and I don't need another 1B while I have Konerko.
I'm in a shallow points league, no keeper. Here's my team:
SP: Weaver, Ubaldo, Nolasco, CJ Wilson, Dan Hudson, Chacin, Jaime Garcia
RP: Marmol, Street, Feliz, Madson
C Matt Wieters
1 Ryan Howard
2 Chase Utley
3 Evan Longoria
OF Nelson Cruz
OF Matt Holliday
Util Gaby Sanchez
BN Drew Stubbs
SP: Halladay, Cahill, Oswalt, Hamels, Gio Gonzalez, Billingsley
RP: Soria, Perez, Hanrahan, Salas
I don't want too many pitchers either so added CJ Wilson to the deal for Prado, but he's turned that down flat....
WHIR 100%, please help make suggestions. Do I stay put or keep trying for this deal?