trumbo or smoak?

[browdee12]

Im in a 14 team head to head 6x6 with holds and obp. Smoak jt hit the waiver wire and I already have trumbo. Just needing some second opinions.
C. R martin
1. Trumbo
2. Pedroia. Uggla
3. Reynolds. Chipper
Ss. Tulow
Lf. Joyce
cf. Gardner. Span
Rf. Stanton. Dom brown
Util. D ortiz and ryan Roberts
Mauer on the dl

Or should I try to package a couple people and try to get a stud 1b?

[avsfan4ever33]

I prefer Smoak, but it's somewhat close (in a one year league at least).