Wainwright or Bumgarner

[T Long]

Who would you rather have in a keeper league, Adam Wainwright or Madison Bumgarner?

[avsfan4ever33]

Wainwright, no question. The only downside is he won't play again until next season, but he is a bonafide ace.

[bginda2g]

Wainwright, no question. The only downside is he won't play again until next season, but he is a bonafide ace.

Agreed

[lane_anasazi2]

What are the keeper rules? Can you keep guys forever, with no penalty?

Wainwright WAS an ace... no telling what he's like when he comes back. If there are limits/contracts involved I'd still take Wainwright. He IS really good. However in a dynasty format where there's no limit to keepers or how long you can keep them, I might go Bumgarner simply because he's a better bet to pay off over the long haul.