Replacing Posey! R.Martin or Arencibia? WHIR

[medium_robin]

9-team keeper league...had Posey, so I haven't been following catchers all that much.

3 guys that interest me...R. Martin, JP Arencibia, and Lucroy. Martin has the "better" track record and is on pace for a good year, though his average has slipped a little lately. Arencibia has the better upside. Lucroy has a crazy BABIP and poor home/road splits, but he's at the top of Yahoo's Transaction Trends. My guess is that Martin isn't available in most leagues. Should I get him or roll with Arencibia?

[V]

Um. How the hell is Russell Martin not owned? He's a must-own in a 6 teamer.

[medium_robin]

Um. How the hell is Russell Martin not owned? He's a must-own in a 6 teamer.

I have no idea. Somebody just picked up Molina (Stl) too, so there's been some shuffling at catcher in my league lately. Anyways, I picked up Martin.

[Millhouse]

Martin. Hands down.

See mine? Thx. viewtopic.php?t=431681