May get Josh Hamilton...

[DramaticChipmunk]

I play in a Roto 5x5 (AVG, R, RBI, HR, SB | ERA, WHIP, K, W, S)

I have been offered Josh Hamilton + Stephen Drew / Elvis Andrus for my Tommy Hanson, Dan Uggla, and Coco Crisp. I'm obviously worried about my 2B filler if Uggla is gone, but it's an enticing offer. We play C, 2B, SS, 2B/SS, 1B, 3B, 1B/3B, 5 OF and 1 UTIL.

Here is my team:

C - Miguel Montero
CI - Greg Dobbs, K. Youkilis, R. Roberts
MI - D. Uggla, Justin Turner, J.J. Hardy
OF - C. Gonzalez, Adam Jones, R. Davis, C. Crisp, D. Stubbs, J. Bruce, J. Damon
DL - Ike Davis

SP: T. Hanson, M. Garza, H. Bailey, J. Shields, M. Latos, J. Tomlin, R. Romero
RP: B. Wilson, H. Street, F. Francisco, J. Walden

Any thoughts one way or the other?

[jruffus1]

I think your outfield is fine and that you would be seriously hurting your pitching by making this trade, especially since Garza is on the DL now.

[Millhouse]

I'd do Hamilton/Andrus for Hanson/Uggla/Coco. But I'm one of those "stud bats are always better than stud pitchers" guys. And if you need a starter later you can package a couple of your lesser OF's and a lesser P for a upgrade.

See mine? Thanks. viewtopic.php?f=26&t=431681