MCab for Haren Help

[jaredmack]

In my one 10 person H2H
i was offered my miguel cabrera for dan haren and casey mcgehee
i have ryan roberts at 3rd base as david wright is out and hurt

i have eric hsomer on my bench but do you think itd be a better trade if i tried to get gaby sanchez instead of mcgehee?

any help will be returned if you leave a link

[Fpower]

No.

No.

No.

No counter offer. No Trade. No way.

[zomberg]

No.

No.

No.

No counter offer. No Trade. No way.

Them's fighting words.

If you're dying for pitching - and in H2H I find that hard to do - I'd try for Sanchez and Haren. But you should feel blown away by a trade offer for such a consistent star hitter...

[ahcryky]

Terrible trade for you. I would want a like Konerko/Youklis type 1B and top tier SP for Cabrera........ Haren wouldn't do it for me!

[Baxter]

I wouldn't do this. Miggy is top 5 even top 2 so Haren/McGehee isn't even close.

[jaredmack]

sorry frogot to put up chris perez if it was mcgehee. woops
but i am a gaby believer which is what i was asking about
and i am in need of pitching on my team

[billycent]

M-Cab is fantasy gold... u don't let him go for anything less than top dollar... Haren and Mcgehee or Sanchez is not that. + in a 10 team waiver pitching should be plentiful. In short... No way. Take a look at mine please?

viewtopic.php?t=431535

[ensanimal]

There is only 2/3 SP's I would consider in a package deal to be giving up MCab, and Haren is not one of those guys.

[KaPluie]

Absolutely not. Cabrera is a top-10 (maybe top-5) fantasy player overall. Haren is a top-15 fantasy pitcher. Pass.

seeking help on viewtopic.php?t=431562

[jpbusta]

I wouldn't even do it if it were Halladay instead of Haren.