Halladay/Morneau for Miguel Cabrera?

[Singles]

I could really use a big bat. Is this a good offer?

H2H 10 team. Re-draft. Daily Transactions.
Batters Stat Categories:
R, HR, RBI, SB, TB, AVG, OPS
Pitchers Stat Categories:
W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, K/BB, QS
C Matt Wieters
1B Adam Dunn
2B Dustin Pedroia
3B Casey McGehee
SS Derek Jeter
IF Justin Morneau
OF Drew Stubbs
OF Chris Young
OF Nick Markakis
OF Michael Bourn
UT Nick Swisher
UT Scott Rolen
BN Domonic Brown
DL Shane Victorino
SP Roy Halladay
SP Francisco Liriano
SP James Shields
SP Gio Gonzalez
SP Jordan Zimmerman
SP Hiroki Kuroda
SP Homer Bailey
RP Jordan Walden
RP Mark Melancon
RP Fernando Salas
DL Brad Lidge

[mgerrish@johare.com]

Too much if you ask me and I am Miggy owner and think he is awesome...

[Metric81]

I would say don't do it, I think you're hitting is fine and without Roy your pitching would not be that strong.

Can you check mine and see what you think?

[zomberg]

You could use a bat, but I think you're overpaying.

[Baxter]

I think you do this. Sure you lose alot in your rotation but you"ll be alright. You can definitely use a big bat and Cabrera is one of the best. This trade improves your team, big time.

[ahcryky]

The only way that I could even see that you would even be a little over paying is if Morneau was actually hitting....... Which he is not. I think it's a good deal for you if you can get it. Easily a top 10 hitter..... You don't pass those type guys up when you can get them, especially with your 1B slot slumping..........

[ensanimal]

I'd grab MCab. Probably end up being a good deal for both teams involved, but I usually like getting the best player. Both main guys are 6 stat guys in this league, but the big bat will usually always win out in h2h.

[kidsilk]

Its a good offer for sure. I hope it gets accepted for you. MCab is awesome. Like it was already said the deal could work out for both parties but I think you win out with this one.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=431547