Trade Help

[DirtDiver]

I volunteered to take over a team that someone pretty much gave up on. So I was left with a mess to fix up. I was just offered this trade:

He wants to give me Justin Morneau and Starlin Castro
and I will give up Lance Berkman and Matt Capps

I myself don't think it's a good trade..So I countered with this trade

I will give him Lance Berkman and Matt Capps
and he will give me Carlos Gonzalez...

Does this seem like a good trade?

[ahcryky]

Is this a keeper league? Would help to see your line up. Either trade seems fair.

[onitapgr]

Is this a keeper league? Would help to see your line up. Either trade seems fair.

I agree...if you can keep Morneau and Castro

[DirtDiver]

We are voting now on making it a keeper league next year. So far it looks like it will be a keeper league

Here is my roster..and like I said before..I inherited this team

Batters

Chris Iannetta
(Col - C)
Howie Kendrick
(LAA - 1B,2B,OF)
Neil Walker
(Pit - 2B,3B)
Jhonny Peralta
(Det - 3B,SS)
Erick Aybar
(LAA - SS)
Justin Upton
(Ari - OF)
Drew Stubbs
(Cin - OF)
Lance Berkman
(StL - 1B,OF)
Carlos Peña
(ChC - 1B)
Derek Jeter
(NYY - SS)
Darwin Barney
(ChC - 2B,SS)
Ryan Zimmerman
(Was - 3B) DL

Pitchers

Ian Kennedy
(Ari - SP)
Hiroki Kuroda
(LAD - SP)
Jair Jurrjens
(Atl - SP)
Matt Capps
(Min - RP)
Ryan Madson
(Phi - RP)
Justin Masterson
(Cle - SP,RP)
Grant Balfour
(Oak - RP)
Ricky Nolasco
(Fla - SP)
Derek Lowe
(Atl - SP)
Homer Bailey
(Cin - SP)
Jonathan Broxton
(LAD - RP) DL

[ahcryky]

Team isn't terrible...... Both trades would help you in a keeper. Need to work on your pitching staff a bit. You could sell high on Peralta, or trade Jeter, and upgrade pitching. There are definitely pieces you could fill with some trading.