Hanson/Castro/Crisp for Tulo in a keeper?

[twistedude]

Hey guys, I'm thinking about making an offer for Tulo in my 15 team yahoo roto KEEPER 5x5.

Is dealing away Hanson worth it for the upgrade from Castro to Tulo? Am I giving up enough/too much in this offer?

C: Martin
1B: Votto
2B: Kinsler
3B: Bautista
SS: Castro
IF: Hosmer
LF: Morrison
CF: Ellsbury
RF: Guerrero
UTIL: Crisp
BN: Lowrie, Jennings, Turner
DL: Ike Davis

SP: Verlander, Kershaw, Hanson, Cahill, Lohse, Dempster
RP: Papelbon, Putz, Guerrier, W. Lopez
DL: Chapman

[ahcryky]

If you can get the other manager to accept this, there is no way you don't offer this. You are getting the best player in the deal..... EASILY! Crisp can't stay healthy, Hanson's a stud, but your staff can take the hit. In a 15 team keeper if you can get him you have to do it, it makes your bats even more stronger.

[twistedude]

Other manager says he wants Hosmer instead of Crisp. Still do it?

[ahcryky]

Other manager says he wants Hosmer instead of Crisp. Still do it?

In a keeper Hosmer, speculation, is gold. What's his roster look like?