Should I do this deal? WHIR

[BlueJaysFan]

I give: Marmol and Scott
I get: Choo and M. Cabrera

The original deal was

I give: Marmol and Kubel
I get: Choo and J. Garcia

I wasn't sure I liked it and the other manager sent me this now. I really like Garcia, but maybe this is better, as I get to keep Kubel and get Cabrera for a guy i was thinking of dropping. Cabrera has been on fire so far, I'm just not sure he'll keep it up. If I don't do the deal, I'll drop Scott for D. Brown.


MY TEAM:

C JP Arencibia
1B Miguel Cabrera
2B Ian Kinsler
3B Plácido Polanco
SS Starlin Castro
OF Matt Joyce
OF Curtis Granderson
OF Nick Swisher
Util Aramis Ramirez
Util Mark Teixeira
Util Adam Dunn
Util Ryan Howard
BN Ryan Ludwick
BN Jed Lowrie
BN Erick Aybar
BN Jason Kubel
BN Luke Scott
DL Travis Hafner
DL Nelson Cruz

SP Jake Peavy
SP Tim Hudson
RP Joakim Soria
RP Brian Wilson
RP Brandon League
P Carlos Marmol
P Mark Melancon
p Alexi Ogando
P Zach Britton
P Mariano Rivera
P Matt Guerrier

SCORING:

Batters Stat Category Value
Runs (R) 1
Singles (1B) 1
Doubles (2B) 2
Triples (3B) 3
Home Runs (HR) 4
Runs Batted In (RBI) 1
Stolen Bases (SB) 2
Caught Stealing (CS) -1
Walks (BB) 0.5
Strikeouts (K) -1
Errors (E) -2

Pitchers Stat Category Value
Innings Pitched (IP) 1
Wins (W) 10
Losses (L) -5
Complete Games (CG) 3
Shutouts (SHO) 3
Saves (SV) 4
Earned Runs (ER) -1
Home Runs (HR) -1
Walks (BB) -1
Strikeouts (K) 1
Blown Saves (BSV) -2

[friedrich15]

i would take the original deal personally ...you can afford to trade and closer and im not a fan of kubel....choo and jamie is the way to go ...good luck.....can you help me



viewtopic.php?t=431204

[BlueJaysFan]

I'm not sure he'll do the original deal any more. If he doesn't should I do this one?

[friedrich15]

if he wont do the original personally i would take this one too....like you said if melky fades grab brown ...your getting a solid hitter on a hot team for a closer...i like having a top close but the lose there job or get hurt and lose their value just as quick....look at mine

viewtopic.php?t=431204

[sigriffey]

I agree. Try hard to land Jaime and Choo, but settle for deal 2 if u must since it's worth it to land Choo IMO.

[whitheadsuxs]

say offer him wilson or mariano for choo and garcia what do u care look at ur savers you have all of the good ones LoL carlos marmol brian wilson and mariano riveria


scott and wilson/ riveria

for choo garcia

you can afford to lose a top notch closer because u have 3 monsters LoL

there was some time last year where choo was considered a top 10-15 outfeilder this slow start people have forgotten but he is a monster ona team wigging out without much help from him

[BlueJaysFan]

Thanks for the help so far. I negotiated to this deal.

I get: Choo, Garcia, Cabrera
I give: Ramirez, Marmol, Scott

It's the same deal as the last one, but I managed to get Garcia for Ramirez. I think this is the best I can do, plus I like Kubel more than ramirez this year. The other manager said he'd do it. Are there any reasons not to do it?

[Seanyfever]

I would have taken the original deal....