hot4tx wrote:From here to the rest of the season who would you rather have - Scherzer or Liriano - and why? This in a 5x5 HTH league with no IP limits.
Lastly do you consider this relatively close or in your opinion is there a huge difference at the moment?
Mighty Max, and it's not even close. Basically, even if Liriano rights the ship (big "if," despite his last start -- something ain't right with that boy), his ceiling for the rest of the year is basically Scherzer's baseline. Scherzer will give you more Ks and more wins without any doubt, and will almost definitely give you a better ERA and WHIP.
Like I said, not close.