dealin cargo WHIR

[fierro33]

would u give up cargo for lincecum and gaby sanchez in a 10 team shallow h2h 5x5 ?


c ianetta
1b dunn
2b cano
3b aramis
ss hanley
of cargo
of mccutchen
of stubbs
util bj upton

pena
rios

halladay
sabathia
shields
romero
bucholz
kennedy
hellickson
lowe

santos
farnsworth
melancon
guerrier

soto DL

[DerekBDoherty]

NO. Wait on CarGo, he will heat up and he will go on a tear when it gets warm in Colorado. This is a bad trade even in deeper leagues, but especially bad in a league like yours. Sanchez just doesn't have much value in a shallow league (especially on your team), and not nearly enough to make up for the gap between Lincecum and CarGo.

[Willy T 4 MVP]

i would give up cargo for lincecum in any league at any time. however, in a 10 teamer gaby sanchez isn't worth much. so if you're cool with lincecum for cargo (which i am), then go ahead and do it. you are not selling low on cargo.



help w mine? viewtopic.php?t=431133

[emenewe5]

Hmmmm...

This is the 2nd post today...involving Lincecum...that I'm considering moving from my "never trade an elite position player for a pitcher".

Car-Go's my boy...love the guy. But, he's having a predictable sophomore slump and now a groin pull (and those scare me!). You can move BJ to the OF and Gabby to the UTI. And adding Timmy to your SP's makes you nearly unbeatable there. Tim's a proven top-3-5 SP and Car-Go's given us a 1-year sample.

If Car-Go was looking good and totally healthy, I'd say no. Given that there are some legit concerns there and you can just set your SP's and forget about it after this deal, I'm leaning towards yes.

Mine? viewtopic.php?t=431138