Trade Aaron Hill for Derek Jeter

[weerez102]

Hi all,
I am in a Yahoo roto league and I was asked to trade Hill for Jeter. I am last in my league in HRs. Looking at last year's I don't know if it is a good idea, but I wanted some feed back.

My Line Up
C – McCann (Atl)
1B – Morneau (Min)
2B – Hill (Tor)
3B – Longoria (TB)
SS – Andrus (Tex)
OF – B.J. Upton (TB)
OF – G. Jones (Pit)
OF – Swisher (NYY)
UT – Cuddyer (Min)
UT – Crisp (Oak)
BN – Rolen (Cin)
BN – Peralta (Det)
BN – Bourn (Hou)
SP – Cain (SF)
SP – Cahill (Oak)
SP – Garcia (StL)
SP – C.J. Wilson (Tex)
SP – Pineda (Sea)
SP – McClellan (StL)
SP – Sanchez (Fla)
RP – Bell (SD)
RP – Melancon (Hou)
RP – Contreras (Phi)

[avsfan4ever33]

I don't see any reason to make this deal... it's questionable if Jeter would be an upgrade over Andrus, and if you're last in homers, it doesn't make sense to trade someone who could help dig you out of that whole for someone who certainly won't.

[dannahann]

You are pretty much trading craptastic for craptoastic at this stage. At least the craptastic Mr Hill is swiping some bags and has the potential to turn things around from a a power standpoint. Jeter is stale moldy old toast now and even more so from a power perspective. i'd pass.

[Tex]

I'd keep Hill if HRs are your concern. Andrus is better than Jeter across the board, and still has room to grow.

[weerez102]

Thank you all for the feedback.