With this point system who would you want?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

This is a follow up to a post I had a couple of days ago that got too long. You guys really helped me out with that one and I hope you can help me out with this one. The league is an auction league, 300 dollar cap, 24 player rosters, points league(see below).

Points Breakdown

Batters Stat Category Value
Runs (R) 1
Singles (1B) 1
Doubles (2B) 2
Triples (3B) 3
Home Runs (HR) 4
Runs Batted In (RBI) 1
Stolen Bases (SB) 2
Caught Stealing (CS) -1
Walks (BB) 1
Hit By Pitch (HBP) 1
Strikeouts (K) -0.5
Ground Into Double Play (GIDP) -2

Pitchers Stat Category Value
Innings Pitched (IP) 2.25
Wins (W) 7
Losses (L) -5
Shutouts (SHO) 5
Saves (SV) 7
Hits (H) -0.5
Earned Runs (ER) -1
Walks (BB) -1
Hit Batters (HBP) -1
Strikeouts (K) 0.5
Batters Grounded Into Double Plays (GIDP) 1
Holds (HLD) 5
No Hitters (NH) 10
Quality Starts (QS) 3
Blown Saves (BSV) -3

My Team:

C-Olivo
1B-MCab
2B-Phillips
SS-Hanley
3B-Walker
OF-Kemp
OF-Lee
OF-Hart
UTI-Joyce
BN-Adam Jones
BN-Byrd
BN-Maybin

SP-Lowe
SP-Volstad
SP-Cain
RP-Rodney
RP-Feliz
P-Wolf
P-Norris
BN-Chen
BN-Tillman
BN-Gonzalez
BN-Jensen
DL-Esmil Rogers

I have been offered Cliff Lee and Alfonso Soriano for My Matt Kemp and Carlos Lee. I would also be losing a dollar in the deal. Would you do it looking at the scoring or stand pat?

[redbeard86]

I'm personally having a problem with Lee so I would keep Kemp but I think I would try to get Soriano

[HOOTIE]

Is this a keeper league?
Normally, i don't like trading a stud bat for a stud arm.
But Lee looks big in this format.

[redbeard86]

lee does get more singles doubles and triples but soriano has more total bases due to his number of home runs. my only worry for you is that soriano does strikeout more

[kidsilk]

Sorry, yeah, it is a keeper league. 16 teams too.

[redbeard86]

in that case i think lee would be great for a keeper but i personally do like kemp

any help with my forum as well would be appreciated.

viewtopic.php?t=430873

[sigriffey]

I'm actually not a huge Soriano guy ... he leaves you hanging with an injury or just goes on offensive vacation for long stretches (like Carlos Beltran).

That said, I think it could be worth doing to get Cliff Lee. I also think Carlos Lee isn't such a bad guy to move to Soriano, as they both have their ups and downs. I love dominant pitching and the Phils offense stands to improve once Utley and Brown are there so I lean yes on this.

[sowen246]

Interesting...

I think I would do this. Yes, there are concerns with Soriano's injuries, but Kemp is striking out at a rate that seems to point to some decline from where he is now. Cliff Lee is a stud, so I see you getting the better side of this deal..

Thanks for looking at mine

[Eastman19]

I would do this trade even know it kills your outfield. I would check waivers for Joyce or another outfielder. Lee is a stud. He is struggling a little right now but when he finds it he is one of the best in the game. Good Luck!!

[HOOTIE]

Sorry, yeah, it is a keeper league. 16 teams too.

I would keep Kemp then. He's in his prime. No sense in getting way older.