Josh Hamilton Trade....WHIR

[casem2k2]

12 team roto
R, HR, RBI, SB, OBP, W, k, sv, era, whip



I trade: Heyward/Liriano

I get: Josh Hamilton


c suzuki
c arencibia
1b morneau
2b Uggla
3b a.ramirez
ss hanley
ci konerko
mi phillips
of werth
of heyward
of rasmus
of pence
util choo
util bourn
b brantley
dl furcal
dl wells

sp gallardo
sp liriano
sp cain
sp j.garcia
rp krod
rp hanrahan
p downs
p adams
p bard
b w.rodriguez
b d.hudson
b c.lewis
b j.sanchez

[lyons595]

IDK...looks like you have Choo? Is that his roster?

[casem2k2]

wow my bad....didnt mean for that to be in the question

[ahcryky]

I would do it

[casem2k2]

any more help?

[Kimbos Beard]

I am all over this trade if I am you. I am not a Liriano fan and see him having very little value in this trade. Hamilton is a proven commodity the only question is whether he will stay healthy (and hopefully avoid a relapses). Heyward is a young talent but has underperformed and has also been unable to stay healthy. So in this situation I go with the proven commodity every time!

Mine - viewtopic.php?f=26&t=438754

[ensanimal]

I would do this. Liriano is pretty meh while Hamilton should be a big upgrade over Heyward for this year.

[kslates]

I see it basically being Heyward for Hamilton as Liriano is WW or better. Heyward has the higher upside but Hamilton is solid and consistent. Go with Hamilton

Help me?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=438755

[Element]

I would do this. Liriano is pretty meh while Hamilton should be a big upgrade over Heyward for this year.

Agreed.

[Urban Cohorts]

I like the trade. Go get Hamilton!