My Stubbs for his Rios + Wandy + Pick? WHIR

[alexeroberts]

In a 11 team 5x5 keep your 5 best keeper league. Overloaded on speed. Trying to get better Avg mostly and equal value for stubbs.

A manager is offering me Rios + Wandy + a 9th round pick in next years draft (14th round overall after 5 rounds of keepers) for Stubbs. Seems like a great deal but I am worried about trading a producing guy for a cold one. What do you think? Thanks. Will help in return...

[ahcryky]

In a keeper I don't do this trade. You're trading a 30/30 guy, potentially 40/40.......... Wandy is lower tier SP for me...... Who would you be dropping to make this deal.....

[alexeroberts]

In a keeper I don't do this trade. You're trading a 30/30 guy, potentially 40/40.......... Wandy is lower tier SP for me...... Who would you be dropping to make this deal.....

either luke scott (which means putting reyonlds back into my lineup) or stauffer.

thanks for the feedback.

[ahcryky]

What bats are on your wire, and it might help to post your team.