Justin Upton for Drew Stubbs

[cs3]

my Upton for his Stubbs + a 13th pick in 2012 in a keeper league.
this may seem like a bad trade because their ADP's were miles apart but im considering accepting it.
My team is tops in the league in 5 of the 6 offensive categories, but im dead last in steals (altho i somehow managed to win it 3 times so far)
stats are Runs, HR, RBI, SB, Hits, OBP
I would give up RBI and OBP, and probably a few homeruns and gain SB's.
also for the past 2 weeks Upton sits on my bench at least half the time because Granderson has been so hot. (we start 4 OF)

another factor is that if i keep J.Up hes a 6th rounder, which is probably great value.
however Stubbs is a 13th rounder, which may be even more valuable?
do i pull the trigger?

heres my roster:
Batters
C: Carlos Santana (C,1B)
1B: Miguel Cabrera (1B)
2B: Jed Lowrie (2B,3B,SS)
3B: Kevin Youkilis (1B,3B)
SS: Starlin Castro (SS)
OF: Matt Holliday (OF), Curtis Granderson (OF), Jose Bautista (3B,OF), Jacoby Ellsbury (OF),
Util: Prince Fielder (1B)
BN: Justin Upton (OF), Eric Hosmer (1B)
DL: Tsuyoshi Nishioka (2B,SS)
Pitchers
SP: Brandon Morrow (SP), Michael Pineda (SP), Daniel Hudson (SP)
RP: Craig Kimbrel (RP), Sergio Santos (RP)
P: Jordan Walden (RP), Huston Street (RP)
BN: Jon Lester (SP), Max Scherzer (SP), Mat Latos (SP), Brandon Beachy (SP), Bud Norris (SP)
DL: Brad Lidge (RP), Stephen Strasburg (SP)

[T bleep O]

Personally I like Stubbs more. They are both great outfielders with fairly equal numbers but the difference in their average year to year production is Stubb's stolen bases. I would pull the trigger I think Stubbs is in a better lineup and in my opinion is more likely to "breakout" this year.

[HOOTIE]

No. Stubbs is good, but Upton has MVP talent. Not close to me.

[cs3]

No. Stubbs is good, but Upton has MVP talent. Not close to me.

what round would the draft pick have to be for you to make this trade?

[rjforlife]

Upton could be an MVP but honestly Stubbs is doing it right now, plus you get a great keeper upgrade round-wise, and a pick. I like the deal, maybe try to squeeze out a 10th rounder or something?



Help:

viewtopic.php?t=430267

[cs3]

anyone else?

[sixer03fan]

[quote="rjforlife"]Upton could be an MVP but honestly Stubbs is doing it right now, plus you get a great keeper upgrade round-wise, and a pick. I like the deal, maybe try to squeeze out a 10th rounder or something?[/quote]

I pretty much agree with this

[HOOTIE]

No. Stubbs is good, but Upton has MVP talent. Not close to me.

what round would the draft pick have to be for you to make this trade?

I would never trade Upton in a keeper, unless i was blown away.
Stubbs and a pick isn't imo.

[whitheadsuxs]

how many do you keep i think when its all said and done call me crazy justin upton and curtis granderson should end around the exact same numbers

what if u went to trade curtis granderson (because of his hotness right now ) get your drew stubbs get a even better pick next year i no were all lovin curtis granderson but lets not be prisoners of this small moment

[cs3]

i tried to trade to trade Granderson, seems nobody is a believer but me in my league.
I just couldt get anyting of value for him, so hes worth more to me than what id get in a trade