Trade Albert Pujols? Good deal

[footballmaniac]

Was just offered the deal below. this is a H2H league and my next best offensive player is Youkilis/Ike Davis. My top pitchers are haren/hudson/Chacin. I won last year because my pitching was crazy but this year I missed the draft.

I get
Lance Berkman, StL 1B
David Price, TB SP
Max Scherzer

I send
Albert Pujols, StL 1B
Wandy Rodriguez, Hou SP
Brennan Boesch, Det OF

[whitheadsuxs]

not ina million years would that be good enough for me if i owned albert pujols if ur gonna sink this year for not being at the draft sink with the best player in the league doing his best in august to keep u afloat or demand an arm and a leg which he is worth

that deal no way

[footballmaniac]

If I countered with the following, you think its enough or am I now pushing it?

Holliday
Price
Max Scherzer
Berkman

for
Pujos
Wandy or Nolasco or Chachin
Boesch

[whitheadsuxs]

i wouldnt do anything unless it was like pujols for holiday sherzer and telll em u want something else as well he can pick if not chuck the duces to the guy dont let em low ball you cause ur vulnerable right now

[Lofunzo]

Generally speaking, I need to get the other team's best player and I need to be overwhelmed to give up Pujols. Neither of those deals accomplishes that.

[whofox]

I can understand that you might need to make a trade for depth if you missed your draft but I'd ask for more for Pujols.

You can always post these trade offers or ideas on tradebashers.com. You input the players and league details and the community of managers votes on which side of the trade they'd prefer to receive. So you know exactly how reasonable or lopsided a deal might be. It also helps when dealing with other managers so that instead of just saying, "your offer stinks," you can say "87% of managers think your offers stinks."