Flip Youk for McCutchen?! Help...WHIR

[wingman3110]

12 team 5x5 roto non-keeper

I get McCutchen and give Youk...what do you guys think? My team looks like this:
C- Montero
1B- Ryan Howard
2B- Cano
3B- Youklis
SS- Tulo
OF- Pence
OF- Bruce
OF- Hart
UT- Bourn
UT- S. Castro
Bn- Figgins
Bn- Hill
DL- Ryan Zimmerman

SP- Latos
SP- Cain
RP- Soria
RP- Hanrahan
P- Melancon
P- Francisco
P- Scherzer
Bn- Garza
Bn- De La Rosa
Bn- Morrow

Leave a link and ill help you out

[aqr135]

I'd definitely keep Youk. He's better than McCutchen and much more consistent.
Help please? viewtopic.php?t=430093

[ahcryky]

That would definitely help your OF..... If you think you can hold out until mid June for Zimmerman, I would do it.

[kaiser]

No, I would hold on to Youk. Better player, more power, better chance to produce runs and rbi, and multi-position eligible.

Should I give Hamels to get Haren? Help here?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=430102

[ahcryky]

No, I would hold on to Youk. Better player, more power, better chance to produce runs and rbi, and multi-position eligible.

Should I give Hamels to get Haren? Help here?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=430102

2010

Youklis - 77/19/62/4/.307
Cutch - 94/16/56/33/.286

This year, pretty similar numbers with McCutchen's AVG starting to creep up a bit in the past couple weeks. Trade talks are coming up for Youklis, not having that line up around him....... hmmmmmmmmm

[wingman3110]

No, I would hold on to Youk. Better player, more power, better chance to produce runs and rbi, and multi-position eligible.

Should I give Hamels to get Haren? Help here?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=430102

2010

Youklis - 77/19/62/4/.307
Cutch - 94/16/56/33/.286

This year, pretty similar numbers with McCutchen's AVG starting to creep up a bit in the past couple weeks. Trade talks are coming up for Youklis, not having that line up around him....... hmmmmmmmmm

Well of course McCutchen's stats from 2010 will be better than Youk since he missed 200 AB's from injury. Definitely an injury risk though. Man this is tough, it would be so much easier if Zimm wasnt on the DL bc otherwise I'd probably do this in a heartbeat but now I'm starting to think I may need another SP...

[OuTrAgE]

This is tough. Very close.

I'm a big fan of Cutch and the fact that it's just OF instead of individual positions make me lean towards pulling the trigger. Do you think you can milk him a little more and get a small upgrade elsewhere?

viewtopic.php?t=430113