3b Help: Reynolds or McGehee

[tah161]

Reynolds and McGehee are both FA in my league but neither are putting up spectacular numbers so far this year.

My current 3b (who gets the start) is Alex Gordon with Ian Stewart (who I dropped and then picked back up when they brought him back up). Stewart still sucks, and Gordon is still hitting pretty well.

Gordon can also play LF where I currently have Huff starting and Huff on my bench. Both are struggling as well.

I am fine with those 3 options at LF, since it gives me 3 options.

I want to cut Stewart again since he is blowing, and I would need another 3b so I can have some flexibility if Gordon goes into a slump or I need to move him to my LF slot.

So who would be the better add here? Mark Reynolds of Casey McGehee?

My league is head to head with: AVG, Runs, 2b, 3b, HR's, RBI, SB.

My offense looks like this right now:
C: Wieters
1B: A Gonz
2B: Zobrist
3B: Gordon (also LF)
SS: Jeter
LF: Huff (also first, and RF)
CF: Kemp
RF: Heyward
DH: Big Papi
BN: Tabata (LF, and CF)
BN: Stewart (3B)
BN: Span (CF)

So which should I add? or should I look at a catcher?

Thanks, and WHIR!!

[ryetoast93]

I think I would add McGehee. He should turn it around at some point and provide some power and a solid average. I for one cannot live with the .200 average of Reynolds and if he isn't hot, I'm staying away. Help on mine?

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=430023

[avsfan4ever33]

Definitely McGehee.

I think Wieters is fine at catcher for now unless there's a great option out there, but I doubt it.

[etl1692]

Yeah McGehee is your better bet. Reynolds Sucks. Im having the same problem. Help! Please viewtopic.php?f=26&t=430031

[jpbusta]

Like everyone else, I like McGehee over Reynolds. I'm not a believe in Reynolds and I think he's on the downfall. I also love McGehee hitting after Braun and Fielder.