Blockbuster Trade... What do you think? WHIR.

[NikeTxGuy]

a 4 for 4 deal...

MY Shin-Soo Choo, Ike Davis, Melky Cabrera & Francisco Cordero for HIS Jose Bautista, Alex Rios, Sam Fuld & Aubrey Huff.

Thoughts? Should I keep what I have or make the deal?

[ahcryky]

I think you should do this deal. Bautista is the best player in the deal, Rios is starting to heat up, as for what you're giving up, Melky, well, is Melky, unless a deep league, nothing but waiver wire help. Rios will make up for losing Choo. Don't know what's on your wire, but Fuld is wire material.

[bobnerns]

I'd do this trade. You're getting arguably 3 of the best 4 players in the trade (with Bautista, Rios and Huff). You aren't losing much in Melky. Ike Davis is so-so. I guess the one question mark comes with Cordero. Do you have enough depth at pitching (and more specifically closers) to be able to deal him away? If so, definitely jump on this deal.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=430003

[NikeTxGuy]

bump

[Roberto Clemente]

bump

I would protest this trade. You are not giving up enough for J.Bautista. He is arguable the BEST hitter in the majors.

[V]

Bautista is the best player in the trade, and you're not losing much. Easy accept if that was proposed to you. If you're proposing, don't waste your time.