Acquire McCann or Keep Montero? And other thoughts...WHIR

[thatonekid343]

10 team H2H mixed (non-keeper) 7x7 (AVG, HR, R, RBI, TB, SB, OPS; W, L, K, ERA, WHIP, QS, SV)

Should I do this trade:
I get: Brian McCann and Dan Hudson
I give: Miguel Montero and Tim Hudson

And also can you please give your opinion and which team looks better cause I am considering many deals right now.
BLUE indicates a replacement for the player next to it.

My team:
C. Miguel Montero Brian McCann
1B. Paul Konerko
2B. Dustin Pedroia
3B. Evan Longoria Kevin Youkilis
SS. Hanley Ramirez
OF. Matt Kemp
OF. Alex Rios
OF. Vernon Wells Josh Hamilton
UTIL. Kevin Youkilis Justin Morneau
BN. Raul Ibanez Logan Morrison
BN. Luke Scott

P. Tim Hudson Dan Hudson
P. Gio Gonzalez
SP. Jered Weaver
SP. Dan Haren Cliff Lee
RP. Jordan Walden
RP. Craig Kimbrel
BN. Ted Lilly
BN. Jeremy Hellickson
BN. Brandon Morrow

[superjags99]

I'd definitely do that. McCann is a top 5 starter the rest of the year at C and Hudson is vastly underrated in many leagues because of his slow start but I like him going forward.

[BigBlueBomber]

I agree to pull the trigger on that deal. While I like Montero, McCann is the better option for the rest of the season. D. Hudson figures to be a good fantasy option the rest of the way with more upside than T. Hudson due to Ks.

If you don't mind contributing here - viewtopic.php?t=429968

[bobnerns]

I'd definitely do the McCann deal. He's a big upgrade over Montero and losing Tim Hudson for Danny Hudson won't kill you.

And I'd definitely take the blue team upgrades over your current roster.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=430003

[steveb101]

I also really like the option of getting Cliff Lee for Haren. Haren is almost always a sell high option before the midway point of the year. Haren will take a turn south in the second half, and Lee will stay far more consistent.

[thatonekid343]

Tim Hudson has been awesome for for ERA, WHIP and Ws. He fits in perfectly for my team cause I get Ks from other sources like Morrow, Weaver, Haren. And Dan Hudson, I think will be a decrease in Ws just by being on the Diamondbacks, and I am unsure of his control to keep my WHIP respectable.