Huge trade. Advice needed

[triple3play]

In a h2h points dynasty league which side would you rather have: Kemp and Cahill or Braun and Drabek?

[Rmbxr9]

I think I'd take the Kemp/Cahill side. I like that Cahill doesn't face AL east, and overall I'd take Cahill for wins too.

[sixer03fan]

I like Braun over Kemp, but Cahill has looked simply amazing, and Kemp is still great. I'd go Kemp/Cahill.

[ahcryky]

Kemp and Cahill........

[avsfan4ever33]

Another vote for Kemp and Cahill. The gap between the two pitchers is greater then the gap between the two outfielders.

[triple3play]

ok my team is the one with Kemp and Cahill. He put Braun on the block and i said i was interested and he came back with that offer. I love Kemp but just like the consistency that Braun has shown compared to Kemp so i wouldnt mind the slight upgrade. What do you think would be a fair counteroffer or am i best sticking with what i have. We are allowed 12 SP on a roster and no limit on starts (daily lineups) It looks as if he wants to exchange OF and swap his lesser SP for my better SP. So what would be some good counters that would help me:

My team: Alex Gordon, Kemp, Victorino, Heyward, Prado, Cruz (just went on DL). Billingsly, Latos, Sabathia, Anderson, Colby Lewis, Cahill, Chacin, Gallardo, Liriano, Wolf, Lilly, Johnathan Sanchez and Hellickson

His team: Braun. Drabek, Pineda, Beachy, Haren, Porcello, Tomlin, Garland, Gorzelanny, Holland, Loshe, Lowe, Volstad

[triple3play]

bump

[fierro33]

stick with kemp and cahill......braun is great but kemp is great too, he is an sb machine

viewtopic.php?t=430024

[Halo Girl]

I'd go with Kemp/Cahill. I really like Braun, but Kemp is good too. What's puts me over the top is I like Cahill better then Drabek and Cahill is a known commodity.