My Lowrie and Jurrjens for Jaime Garcia? WHIR

[BiGAnT]

Should I do this trade?? Is it even fair? Any thoughts, thanks!!

C Geovany Soto
1B Ryan howard
2B Brandon Phillips
3B Casey McGehee
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Matt Kemp
OF Rajai Davis
OF Vladimir Guererro
Util Alex Rios
BN Jed Lowrie


SP Roy Halladay
SP Chris Carpenter
SP Jair Jurrjens
RP Jordan Walden
RP Brandon League
P Brandon McCarthy
P Randy Wolf
P Bartolo Colon
P Vicente Padilla
P Sergio Santos
P Mark Melancon
P Aroldis Chapman

[whitheadsuxs]

do vlad straight up for him its jeds breakout year but you do need to figure out ur pitching staff as far as starting pitchers is concerned i think its jurrjenns year 2 finally live up to the hype him and tommy hanson both braves bats are swinging hot see i think ur giving too much jed hasnt shown signs of slumping and has been putting numbers up for a minute in boston now i say no

[WhiteSoxFan]

I honestly think that Jurrjens is basically Garcia's equal. No need to throw in Lowrie as well. I don't know...I'm not sure that you'd obtain an advantage here. I would try to hang onto Jurrjens and get another solid pitcher if possible.

[sman79]

I'd stick with what you have on this one.

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=429925

[cmcdonal2001]

Pass on this one. Jurrjens has been pretty lights out so far, and he's got a solid team behind him. MAYBE I'd do it straight up for Garcia, but Lowrie is definitely worth hanging on to. He'll probably be fairly consistent, and he has a big upside.



Please take a look at mine: viewtopic.php?t=429916

[HOOTIE]

I would do it. But i suppose it depends on what bat you can pick up for your bench?
Fwiw, i would replace Colon too.

Jurrgens is a nice SP. But be aware is K/9 is under 6 right now, and only a bit over 6 in career.
His low era right now is because of a 3.2% hr/fb ratio.

Garcia on the other hand, has a K/9 of just under 9, and over 7 in career.
Jurrgens is hot, but i take Garcia because of the K/9 advantage.

Lowrie is ok, but a .392 babip looks nice.