Is it worth dropping AJ Pierzynski for Miguel Olivio

[gotham]

Is it worth dropping AJ Pierzynski for Miguel Olivio? Your thoughts.... Please.

year to date stats....
Player BA HR R RBI SB
Olivo, Miguel C SEA 0.2000 2 13 10 0
Pierzynski, A.J. C CHW 0.2264 1 5 11 0

5x5 Roto non-keeper 10 team mixed league.

C McCann, Brian(C) ATL
C Pierzynski, A.J.(C) CHW
1B Howard, Ryan(1B) PHI
2B Cano, Robinson(2B) NYY
3B Reynolds, Mark(3B) BAL
SS Jeter, Derek(SS) NYY
MI Andrus, Elvis(SS) TEX
CI Roberts, Ryan(3B,OF) ARI
OF Cuddyer, Michael(1B,2B,OF) MIN
OF Joyce, Matt(OF) TB
OF Kemp, Matt(OF) LA
OF McLouth, Nate(OF) ATL
OF Quentin, Carlos(OF) CHW
OF Victorino, Shane(OF) PHI
U Aybar, Erick(SS) ANA
U Cabrera, Asdrubal(SS) CLE

DL (CI) Sandoval, Pablo(3B) SF
DL (U) Morrison, Logan(OF) FLA

SP Billingsley, Chad(SP) LA
SP Dempster, Ryan(SP) CHC
SP Drabek, Kyle(SP) TOR
SP Haren, Dan(SP) ANA
SP Hernandez, Felix(SP) SEA
SP Kennedy, Ian(SP) ARI
SP Nova, Ivan(SP) NYY
RP Cordero, Francisco(RP) CIN
RP Rivera, Mariano(RP) NYY

[avsfan4ever33]

It's probably more of a lateral move then anything. I'd probably keep AJ just because I like his lineup/ballpark a lot more then Olivo's.

[cmcdonal2001]

Seems to be a toss-up. I'd probably slightly favor AJ as the bats around him are going to heat up eventually, so he should get a few more RBI/Run chances than Olivo will.



viewtopic.php?t=429916

[gotham]

Thanks all.... it just hurts to see AJ putting up junk numbers when some of these other guys are hitting. I have to remember it's a long season, and since I was on the fence anyway, I'll save my move.