FA pickup at C.... WHIR!

[Hamiltond18]

I play in a 12 team head to head standard 5x5 scoring yahoo league. I'm thinking about making a move at catcher. I currently have Napoli and Arencibia on my team. Looking to pick up Jon Buck and drop Napoli, would you do it? Here is my current roster..... Leave a link I will be glad to help you!

My team
Arencibia
Pujols
Kendrick
Zimmerman
Reyes
Polanco
Pence
Rasmus
Hunter
Napoli
Markakis

Pitchers
Johnson
T. Wood
Hudson
Wilson
E. Sanchez
Beckett
Lohse
Cueto
Lidge
Zambrano
Weaver

[timaxman]

Why Buck exactly? I mean you don't have top tier catchers, but it's not like buck is a step up or anything..

[Hamiltond18]

Why Buck exactly? I mean you don't have top tier catchers, but it's not like buck is a step up or anything..

He is one of three full time catchers available and seemed like the best option. My three options would be Buck, Suzuki, and Pierzynski. Should I make a move or stay put?

[timaxman]

if you don't mind platooning what you've got, they will produce better than any tandem involving buck