Bolthead04 wrote:My league has been horribly stingy on accepting trades. Not one trade offered to me has been remotely fair. This is one of the few people who even does trade in my league and he has
as his OF eligibles. So, Swisher and Tabata both had an predraft-ranking (which is what my league is obsessed with apparently) around 125 and Nolasco had one of 178ish. Pitchers are also supposedly worth less than hitters (and this is true in my league as there are 6 batting cats to 5 pitching, and the WW is easy to pick for pitchers....), which means by my leagues standards, I'm underoffering.
If you think I'm giving too much, what caliber OF do you think I can land?
I know where you're coming from. It's almost impossible to get in contact with managers in my league to initiate trade discussions, and when there is a correspondence, it's generally a one sided set of offers with no middle ground. This generally leads me to giving up a little more than I should, but what can I do if I have a need to fill?
Anyway, I think it's definitely a fair offer. I do personally prefer the Tabata side (tend to side with the hitter when the value is close), but if he is in need of pitching and is looking for Nolasco, then Tabata should be a fair deal. Good luck.
Help with mine? Keeper Trade