Is this a fair deal?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

The deal on the table now is:

My Wieters, LaPorta, and Peavy for

His Jose Molina, Ichiro, Rauch, Britton

Would you guys do this one? Please help and leave your links!

[RUnited]

Agreed with above poster on the W and L side of things, except for Wieters. I have Montero and Wieters in my team and Wieters is just racking up way too many K's too quickly. I'm also a biased Wieters fan, but let's be real here, the guy's still a risk on any team in any league.

He'll eventually breakout, but since he won't be among your keepers there's not really a need to keep a hold of him for this season.

Do the deal.

[Conrax]

Thanks for your help. I think you should accept the latest deal. If you don't have Holds as a category then I don't like Rauch because it seems Francisco has already swooped and grabbed one save. Britton if he can keep it is up is a good pitcher. Ichiro gives you consistent hits and some speed. Molina and Wieters is a wash for me like someone else said Wieters is just striking out too much. You also get rid of Peavy who is not getting much run support behind him.

[thejusman1]

As someone said previously, it's just way too complicated to discern the value on both sides. Too many different factors to consider upside/injury implications/how long people will hold onto their jobs (trumbo/rauch). I would try and narrow the trade down first of all.

[T bleep O]

I like this trade for you. It's close but Abreu pushes it over the top, I think he is the best player in the deal, yea Rauch might not have the job but its not unlikely that Frank Francisco either gets hurt or sucks.