QUICK: Melancon or Padilla for saves?

[sigriffey]

It seems like Melancon has the clearer role for saves. take him over Padilla?

[brener]

Its a tough call. Lyon and Broxton have both been brutal. Broxton is supposedly hurt right now so Padilla may be the quicker option and the Dodgers do have a better team than the Astros for more opportunities. If you want a long term replacement i would go with Melancon but if you need saves asap i would probably turn to Padilla.