Tex/McCutchen for my Votto WHIR

[DigitalFool]

Standard 6x6 12 Team H2H ESPN League - 5 keepers

The trade is Tex/McCutchen for Votto.

My current roster (K indicates Keeper from last year):

C: Posey (K)
1B: Votto (K)
2B: Johnson
3B: Reynolds
SS: Reyes (K)
2B/SS: Walker
1B/3B: Dunn
OF: Holliday (K)
OF: J. Upton (K)
OF: Pierre
OF: Hunter
OF: Suzuki
Util: Raburn
BENCH: Desmond
DL: Sandoval
DL: Furcal

Since it is 2 for 1, I'd be dropping Raburn. He'll be getting the best player in the deal IMO, but I'll be upgrading my overall team. Kind of tough for me as I always hate giving up the best player in the trade. Thoughts?

[sixer03fan]

I looks like a good deal to me, but mainly depends on your confidence in McCutchen. If he's going to produce like a top 4 round player this year, then go for it. Votta is ridiculous, but Teix is great too. Personally, I would do this deal.

[MaudDib]

I am going to say no. It is a fair trade but you don't really need an OFer and Votto is better than Tex by a big margin.

[Zhangman1]

I wouldnt do it. Esp in a keeper, I never like giving up the best player (votto)

---
help w/ mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=429637