McCutchen/Gallardo/Cahill for Crawford/Scherzer/Cueto

[RenT]

14 team 5x5 roto keeper league (between 5-7 keepers depending on where you finish). Am I giving up enough by offering:

McCutchen/Gallardo/Cahill for Crawford/Scherzer/Cueto?

Thanks for your help and WHIR... leave a link.

[Ronniebegood]

I think it's fair but to be perfectly honest I think I'd stick with what you have. You have some young solid studs there.

McCutchen (I had Cutch last year, dude is a stud and will play better than he is now, he's a young Carl Crawford)
Gallardo (Has great potential, in a slump granted, I think he turns it around and has the offensive support around him)
Cahill (18 game winners are hard to find)

Crawford (Still adjusting to Fenway, who knows how he'll pan out this year)
Scherzer (Definitely a strike out pitcher but is he any better than Gallardo? Has never won more than 12 games)
Cueto (I had Cueto last year, drove me crazy. Don't think he's better than Cahill)

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=429381