Help on this trade!! WHIR

[etl1692]

What are your thoughts on both trades? Which one is better to benefit me. Are both decent trades for me?

I give Alfonso Soriano, and Kyle Lohse for Aramis Ramierez and Ted Lilly???

Or Alfonso Soriano, Nick Swisher, and Kyle Lohse for Justin Masterson and Alex Gordon??

[KaPluie]

Trade1:
ASoriano+KLohse for ARamierez and TLilly
Advantage: Side getting ARam. Lohse will be back playing like waiver wire fodder soon enough, and ARam>ASor.

Trade2:
ASoriano+NSwisher+KLohse for JMasterson+AGordon
Advantage: Close call. I like the Swisher side to have a better year from this point forward, however the Gordon side sure has started hot! I'd stay put though.

Overall, I think trade1 is great for you, but trade2 is risky, and I'd stay put.

seeking help on viewtopic.php?t=429377

[etl1692]

I can interchange Swisher with Fold if that is better? Dunno if he'll take it though (he is a yankee fan, which is why i threw in swish)?