Pick a side...A or B?

[knittedmonkey]

Side A:
Pujols
N Cruz
Verlander
P Alvarez

Side B:
A Gonz
Kemp
Gallardo
H Bell

[kaiser]

Hard to say without knowing league parameters, but my first inclination is to go with Side A.

[Ronniebegood]

B. Only because of Alvarez.. Side A is a little weaker with him in there.

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=429381

[timaxman]

It's a tough choice.

For a keeper though, I might stick with A. Verlander is a consistent ace, and gallardo has shown that he's not (consistent).

I don't feel like either team is getting screwed over however.

[RASportsnut]

If league is a 5 X 5 (saves a category), I like side B:

Gonzo: elite
Kemp: elite
Gallardo: near elite
Bell: elite

Side A:
Pujols: elite
Cruz: near elite
Verlander: elite
Alvarez: middle of pack

Bell as one of the few elite closers, I'd go with that side.

But, it is close.