How is this trade?

[mfaye9]

Hi,
How is this trade for me?
I trade Tulo, Ludwick, Kubel, McClellan and Gio Gonzalez for Miguel Cabrera, Victorino, and Jurjjens, and Carpenter.

My Team:
C Jorge Posada, NYY C, DH
1B Justin Smoak, Sea 1B
2B Danny Espinosa, Was 2B
3B Mark Reynolds, Bal 3B S
SS Troy Tulowitzki, Col SS
2B/SS Ian Kinsler, Tex 2B
1B/3B Jhonny Peralta, Det SS, 3B
OF Ryan Raburn, Det OF
OF Aubrey Huff, SF 1B, OF
OF Melky Cabrera, KC OF
OF Ryan Ludwick, SD OF
OF Alex Rios, CWS OF S
UTIL Freddy Sanchez, SF 2B
UTIL Carl Crawford, Bos OF
UTIL Jason Kubel, Min OF, DH
Bench Logan Morrison*, Fla OF DL15
Bench Victor Martinez*, Det C, DH DL15
DL Ryan Zimmerman*, Was 3B DL15

P Jon Lester, Bos SP
P Clayton Kershaw, LAD SP PP
P Carlos Marmol, ChC RP
P Trevor Cahill, Oak SP
P Jeremy Guthrie, Bal SP PP
P Gio Gonzalez, Oak SP
P Clay Buchholz, Bos SP DTD
P Kyle McClellan, StL RP, SP
P Brian Sanches, Fla RP
P Eduardo Sanchez, StL RP
P Brandon Morrow, Tor SP
P Brian Duensing, Min SP, RP

[ahcryky]

I think you do this trade. Even though it's tough to let Tulowitzki go, you are getting Cabrera. I like Victorino over both Kubel and Ludwick, and Jurrjens and Carpenter over McClellan and Gio.

[RASportsnut]

I see a couple of things going on with your team. Victor Martinez is due back Wednesday, and assuming he's 1B eligible in your league, you can make him your corner infielder. Morrison will be back in a couple of weeks, so that will solidify your OF better. The big question: who will be your SS? Will you have a large dropoff from Tulo?

I'm not sure I'd do this trade. Yes, Miggy is great, but 1B depth is much greater than SS. I have Tulo also, and I'd be very, very careful before I'd trade him. He's pretty much alone at the SS position right now, with HRam down so far this year.

[mfaye9]

I see a couple of things going on with your team. Victor Martinez is due back Wednesday, and assuming he's 1B eligible in your league, you can make him your corner infielder. Morrison will be back in a couple of weeks, so that will solidify your OF better. The big question: who will be your SS? Will you have a large dropoff from Tulo?

I'm not sure I'd do this trade. Yes, Miggy is great, but 1B depth is much greater than SS. I have Tulo also, and I'd be very, very careful before I'd trade him. He's pretty much alone at the SS position right now, with HRam down so far this year.

I can't really explain it but I think I feel more comfortable with Miggy over Tulo. Also, I think the rest of the trade is great for me. Am I right?
Thanks!