Quick trade help!!!!

[gbill2004]

Should I make this trade?

I get Jason Bay & Chad Billingsley

I give Corey Hart, Jair Jurrjens & Cameron Maybin

--------------------

Competitive 12 team H2H deep re-draft league. Roster below (starting spots in brackets):

C (2) - Buster Posey, Brian McCann
1B (2) - Adam Dunn, Adam Lind, Derek Lee
2B (2) - Brandon Phillips, Gordon Beckham
3B (2) - Kevin Youkilis, Miguel Tejada
SS (2) - Hanley Ramirez, JJ Hardy
OF (4) - Matt Kemp, Sin-Soo Choo, Corey Hart, BJ Upton, Jeff Francoeur, Raul Ibanez

SP (7) - Jered Weaver, Francisco Liriano, John Danks, Ricky Nolasco, Jair Jurrjens, Derek Holland, Kyle McClellan, Michael Pineda, Jon Garland, Johnny Cueto, Jake Peavy (DL)
RP (2) - Heath Bell, Jordan Walden, Mitchell Boggs

[tripleb]

It's pretty even, maybin isnt a difference maker and I like bills over jurjens. Bay could compete with Hart and your Of is ok, I'd do it if you like the bills upgrade. Though you probably lose out with Hart over Bay.

[whofox]

Bay could bounce back but I'd usually side with the guy getting fewer players, all else being equal.

You can always post these offers on tradebashers.com. Input the players and league type and the community votes on which side of the trade they prefer. In the end you see exactly what percent of managers prefer which side of the trade. Adds some hard numbers to the trading game. Instead of just saying "That offer stinks" you can say "87% of managers thought that offer stinks."

[ahcryky]

I don't like it. I see Jurjens and Billingsley as a push, and I don't trust Bay. Line up in Milwaukee is way better then NY for Hart.