Quick advice on Pujols trade!!!

[jbredding]

I'm in need of power & pitching... and got an offer today:

I get: Pujols/Stubbs/Bay/Carpenter
I give up: Kemp/Holliday/Reyes/Butler

Advice? Should I throw McCutchens in for Stubbs?

H2H 12 team keeper league with R/HR/RBI/K/SB/OBP & K/W/L/SV/ERA/WHIP. This is my team:

C - Miguel Montero
1B - BIlly Butler
2B - Neil Walker
3B - Michael Young
SS - Jose Reyes
OF - Carlos Gonzalez
OF - Matt Holliday
OF - Matt Kemp
Ut - Aaron Hill (2B)
Ut - Ian Desmond (SS)
Bench - Chone Figgins (2B/3B)
Bench - Dexter Fowler (OF)
Bentch - Mike Napoli (C)
P - Matt Garza
P - Jaime Garcia
P - Tommy Hanson
SP - Yovani Gallardo
SP - Kyle Lohse
RP - Joakim Soria
RP - Heath Bell
Bench - Madison Bumgarner
DL - Brandon Webb
DL - Adam Wainwright

[tripleb]

No thank you, that's too much. Leaves u vacant at ss and depletes a superb of

[whofox]

If you're comfortable with Desmond as your SS I'd probably do it. Losing Kemp hurts but Stubbs is for real and Pujols is...well, Pujols.

You can always post these offers on tradebashers.com. Input the players and league type and the community votes on which side of the trade they prefer. In the end you see exactly what percent of managers prefer which side of the trade. Adds some hard numbers to the trading game. Instead of just saying "That offer stinks" you can say "87% of managers thought that offer stinks."

[ahcryky]

Maybe if you could sub in McCutchen for Bay......

[dannahann]

You're trading away too much even with the inclusion of McCutcheon.