Hanley Ramirez for Justin Upton/CC Sabathia/Chris Perez?

[V]

12 team 5x5 Roto, 3 keepers year to year. I have OF and RP depth, but CC would be a hit. Hanley (if he recovers from his slump) is a no-doubt keeper. Upton is a potential keeper if he takes a big step forward. CC is probably just not good enough (and I probably wouldn't keep a pitcher if I could help it).

Is this trade OK for me?

C: Wilson Ramos
1B: Kevin Youkilis
2B: Neil Walker
3B: Evan Longoria
SS: Jhonny Peralta
IF: Lance Berkman
OF: Justin Upton
OF: Jayson Werth
OF: Curtis Granderson
OF: Michael Bourn
U: Grady Sizemore
BN: David Ortiz
DL: Aaron Hill

SP: CC Sabathia
SP: Tommy Hanson
SP: Mat Latos
RP: Chris Perez
RP: John Axford
P: Josh Beckett
P: Aaron Harang
P: Ryan Madson
P: Zach Britton
BN: Bartolo Colon
BN: Mike Leake
DL: Andrew Bailey

[dmattingly23]

that's alot to give up.

[V]

that's alot to give up.

Yeah, I'm beginning to believe so myself. It is 3 player keeper league though.

How about for Tulo?

[diesek]

You're giving too much mate whether if its Tulow or Hanley. Try replacing Upton for another player.

[V]

You're giving too much mate whether if its Tulow or Hanley. Try replacing Upton for another player.

Who, though?

Werth is hitting .233 with 7 RBIs, and already had question marks entering the season. I don't see him being accepted. Longoria I have over Upton, and Youkilis probably ditto.

[Singles]

I wouldn't make that trade keeper or not. You have a nice team and you are giving up alot to get a slumping Hanley. Granted Hanley will probably turn it around but you will fill one hole and make 2 others. I wouldn't worry to much about who your 3 keepers are going to be for next year. it is only April. CC is the ace of your staff, Perez is a good closer and Upton could end up being a top 10 OF this year. You have a nice team. i would hold for know.

[V]

Thanks for talking sense into me, guys

1 month in, and I'm solidly 5th-7th in all 10 categories, and really hoping my team can make that move up the ladder.